Thursday, May 23, 2024

Your Meniscus In all probability Doesn’t Care About Your ACL Reconstruction

Meniscal procedures should not elevated with delayed ACL reconstruction and rehabilitation: outcomes from a randomized managed trial.

van der Graaff SJA, Reijman M, van Es EM, Bierma-Zeinstra SMA, Verhaar JAN, Meuffels DE. The British Journal of Sports activities Medication, 2023; 57:78-82.

Full Textual content Freely Obtainable

Take-Dwelling Message

Individuals who initially obtain rehabilitation with an non-compulsory delayed anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction have the same threat for meniscal surgical procedures than these handled with an early ACL reconstruction.


Nonoperative therapy of an ACL rupture is a viable possibility for a lot of sufferers. Nonetheless, some clinicians have raised considerations that nonoperative therapy of an ACL rupture or a delayed ACL reconstruction might improve the danger of meniscal accidents.

Research Objective

van der Graaff and colleagues accomplished a secondary evaluation of information from the COMPARE trial to judge if treating an ACL rupture with a delayed possibility for reconstruction results in extra meniscal procedures than an early ACL reconstruction.


The authors used knowledge collected from the COMPARE trial. The trial included individuals who sustained an acute ACL rupture throughout the prior two months. Eight-five contributors randomly acquired an early ACL reconstruction (inside six weeks of enrolling within the research). Eighty-two contributors randomly acquired nonoperative therapy with an non-compulsory delayed ACL reconstruction. All contributors within the nonoperative group acquired a minimum of 3 months of supervised bodily remedy. After 3 months of structured bodily remedy, contributors may go for an ACL reconstruction. The authors recorded if somebody had a meniscal process throughout an ACL reconstruction or different surgical procedure. Moreover, all contributors had a baseline MRI, which the research staff reviewed for indicators of a meniscal tear.


Half of the contributors who started within the nonoperative group selected to have an ACL reconstruction in the course of the 2-year follow-up interval. At baseline, about 41% of contributors had a meniscal tear, no matter group. About 30% of knees had a meniscal process throughout an ACL reconstruction, regardless of whether or not it was an early or delayed reconstruction. After the reconstruction, 5% of knees required one other meniscal process, no matter group. These subsequent surgical procedures have been due to new trauma or knee complaints, however they all the time concerned a meniscus the authors seen had injury on the unique ACL reconstruction. About 10% of the contributors who by no means acquired an ACL reconstruction had a separate meniscal surgical procedure.


This research clarifies that somebody who tries nonoperative therapy is not going to have at larger threat for a brand new meniscal harm than somebody receiving an early ACL reconstruction. These outcomes agree with outcomes from the KANON trial that discovered related charges of meniscal surgical procedure over 5 years after randomly assigning individuals to an early or an optional-delayed ACL reconstruction.

Scientific Implications

Clinicians needs to be conscious that originally making an attempt nonoperative therapy with somebody with an ACL harm is not going to improve their threat of a meniscal tear that requires surgical procedure. Educating sufferers concerning the execs and cons of delaying an ACL reconstruction may assist a affected person higher consider their choices following an ACL rupture and empower them to decide on the choice that most closely fits their life-style.

Questions for Dialogue

How quickly after ACL harm do you talk about surgical procedure as a possible end result along with your sufferers? Do you additionally talk about the potential for sufferers to be handled nonoperatively?

Written by Kyle Harris
Reviewed by Jeffrey Driban

Associated Posts

Why Sufferers Who Are Handled Nonopertively After an ACL Harm Resolve To Have Surgical procedure
Who Will get a Blood Clot After ACL Reconstruction?
Does Intercourse Influence Psychological Readiness to Return-to-Sport After ACL Reconstruction?
What Occurs within the Household Stays within the Household: Inheriting a Danger of ACL Tears
Folks with an ACL Reconstruction are 5 Occasions Extra Prone to Want a Knee Alternative Later On


Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles

“come posso dire che marc marquez non fa paura ?.